Fayol Vs Mintzberg Essay

Management: Fayol Vs Mintzberg Essay

Critically discuss the extent to which Fayol's classical analysis of the management function has largely been made redundant by the more recent empirical studies of what managers actually do, such as that favoured by Mintzberg.

Introduction
Henri Fayol, at the age of 19, began working as engineer at a large mining company in France which eventually led to him becoming a director. Through the years that led on to this Fayol then developed his 14 principles of management which he considered to be the most important. According to Fayol, these principles indicate how managers should organise and interact with their peers. Fayol’s analysis is considered to be one of the earliest theories of management that has been created and therefore can be considered to be redundant. The many arguments considered in relation to Fayol have been considered throughout this essay as well as my own argument to gain an overall conclusion as to whether Fayol’s classical analysis of management has been made redundant.

Fayol’s perspective on management
Through personal experience, Fayol distinguished what he thought to be the prime functions of being a manager. It is said that he was the first to illustrate the need for the education of management (Brodie, 1967, in Fells, 2000) and in relation to management; Fayol’s perspective was what managers should do. Through categorising business activities into six activities, technical; commercial; financial; security; accounting and management; Fayol’s work focused on the latter category, management (Fells, 2000, pg.345).
Division of work, discipline, span of control, order and equity are just a few of the 14 principles of management that Fayol constructed from his analysis. He stressed that the number of principles, however, were non-exhaustive and that they are flexible and adaptable to every need (Fayol 1949, Brodie 1967, in Fells, 200, pg.346).
His perspective then developed further where he then acknowledged five “elements” or “processes” (Gray 1984 in Fells, 2000, pg.346) of management (Fells, 2000, pg. 346) and planning, organising, co-ordinating, commanding and controlling are these. Fayol suggested that these principles should be used by people within managerial positions when involved in their own management processes.

Mintzberg’s perspective on management
Furthermore, Mintzberg dismissed Fayol’s concept of management from the start and labelled it “folklore” (Mintzberg, 1975). Unlike Fayol suggesting what managers should do Mintzberg identified ten roles in which he believed a manager should undertake in order to be successful within their managerial position. He suggested within his perspective how managers actually behave. His ten roles were then condensed into three different roles, which are, interpersonal, informational and decisional roles - such as leader, entrepreneur, resource allocator and spokesman.

Reconciliation of the two theories
To an extent, I disagree with the statement...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

HOW RELEVENT ARE FAYOLS'S IDEAS TO MANAGIING INDIIDUALS AND GOUPS IN TODAY'S BUSINESS WORLD?

2349 words - 9 pages Henri Fayol was born in 1841 and died in 1925. After 30 years of an eminently successful career as a practitioner, Fayol devoted the remainder of his life, from 1918 to 1925, to promoting his theory of administration. Fayol was perhaps the first to note the need for management education. His

Taylor's Principles of Management Essay

1601 words - 6 pages In this 21st century, management has been observed as both art and science (Reh, 2010). It is an art as it helps people to be more innovative, creative, and effective on doing their job, compare with the previous time when people would have been doing their job without applying the knowledge of management. Likewise, management can be considered as a science in how managers will be able to manage people and help them to involve further and to be...

Describe a manager's morning using Fayol's and Mintzberg's theories.

1585 words - 6 pages Management is a vital component to be recognized in every organization. It can be defined as the process of administering, and coordinating resources effectively and efficiently and in an effort to achieve the goals of the organization (Lewis, Goodman and Fandt, 1998: 5). Without an effective and an efficient management, an organization will not run successfully. The development of the management theories have been characterized by different...

A reflective paper on the four functions of management. And applying them to real life.

1102 words - 4 pages (Reflective Paper)By Roderick SmithGood and effective management is vital to the dynamics of a forward moving society. This is true in all organizations, including business and government. Society could function with ineffective managers and management to some extent but not to its optimum. 'Good' management can map out a path to success whereas poor management may lead to failure and possible collapse. By considering the roles...

Manager in the real world.

1387 words - 6 pages Every organization has the same characteristic, which is they all have managers for running their business, whatever how big the organization is. What is management? As an old fashion issue, people still ask themselves what manages do exactly in organization. As many test books defined initiatively the management are functions of planning, organizing, controlling, commanding and coordinating. (

The Roots of Modern Management Principals

2383 words - 10 pages Modern management principals are still based upon Fayol’s functions, Mintzberg’s roles and Katz ‘s skills even though they have been around for a long time in our dynamic environment. This is evident if you firstly understand what Fayol’s functions, Minzberg’s roles and Katz’s skills actually are and you look into new management texts and businesses. Henri Fayol was general manager of a large coal mining company in 1916 he published a book...

The new managerial thoughts and organisational approaches like empowerment, delegation decentralisation and self-managed teams has ensued the changes as compared to the traditional approach.

1683 words - 7 pages 1. Introduction The role of a manager is rapidly changing and demands a fresh perspective at present situation. The new managerial thoughts and organisational approaches like empowerment, delegation decentralisation and self-managed teams has ensued the changes as compared to the traditional approach. 2. Classical approach of the manager Traditional or classical management focuses on efficiency and includes...

The Managerial Nature of Case Management

4471 words - 18 pages The prominence of case management as a service delivery method and as an area of study for social workers has increased in the past decade. Although case management has its roots in the earliest helping efforts of the social work profession (Ashley, 1988), only recently has this method received a considerable research and practice commitment. (For example, Social Work...

"No job is more vital to society than that of the manager." (Henry Mintzberg). Discuss.

1273 words - 5 pages Good and effective management is vital to the dynamics of a forward moving society. This is true in all organizations, including business and government. Society could function with ineffective managers and management to some extent but not to its optimum. 'Good' management can map out a path to success whereas poor management may lead to failure and possible collapse. By considering the roles of a successful manager we can learn that they are...

What is managment?

1756 words - 7 pages There is no one definition for the term management. However, Fayol (1916) defined the term management as;"To manage is to forecast and plan, to organize, to command, to co-ordinate and to control." Mc Ilwee.T and Roberts I, (1991): p.g117Management is not homogeneous and is undertaken at all levels of the organisation, as it is an integrating activity. Managers have to manage in order to achieve the overall objectives and...

Role of Manager

1344 words - 5 pages Organizations and the Need for Manager* Organization: Two or more people who work together in a structured way to achieve a specific goal or set of goals* Goal: The purpose that an organization strives to achieve; organizations often have more than one goal; goals are fundamental elements of organizations* Manager: People responsible for directing the efforts...

This action might not be possible to undo. Are you sure you want to continue?

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *